| Platinum | The Baker |
| Gold | Holiday Bakery |
| Silver | Goulart Square Bakery |
| Bronze | Sunrise Bakery & Coffee Shop |
| Top Pick | Eli's Pastry Cafe |
| Top Pick | Lorenzo's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Lydia's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Market Basket |
| Top Pick | New York Bagel Co. |
| Top Pick | Rescue Cafe |