| Platinum | Metro Pizza & Sandwiches |
| Gold | Riccardi's Restaurant |
| Silver | Fay's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pa Raffa's |
| Top Pick | Charlie's Place, Wareham, MA |
| Top Pick | Minerva Pizza House |
| Top Pick | Palace Pizza & More |
| Top Pick | Primo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pyramids Pizza & GRLL |
| Top Pick | Salonika House Of Pizza |