| Platinum | Kyler's Catch Seafood Market |
| Gold | Fay's Restaurant |
| Gold | Kyler's Kitchen and Sushi |
| Silver | Blue Point Restaurant |
| Bronze | Fathoms Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Cove Surf & Turf |
| Top Pick | Danny's Seafood |
| Top Pick | Gene's Famous Seafood |
| Top Pick | Merrill's on the Waterfront |
| Top Pick | The Black Whale Gift Shop |