| Platinum | Crust Punks |
| Gold | Acushnet Creamery |
| Silver | Country Whip |
| Bronze | The Acai Spot |
| Top Pick | Dairy Maid |
| Top Pick | Dockside Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Dorothy Cox Chocolates |
| Top Pick | Ground Floor Coffee |
| Top Pick | Surface Creamery |
| Top Pick | The Bucket at Gulf Hill |
